
It’s Spooky Season at last! I’m so excited (can you tell?). Even though we don’t get fall here on the Mexican coast, we do get DÃa de Muertos, which has to be one of the most awesome traditions ever. I’ll be putting out my ghosts and fake pumpkins and pretending I feel a crisp breeze.
I’ll also be traveling to Tepoztlán, which is supposed to be one of the best places to celebrate DÃa de Muertos, with Batalá, my local chapter of the international drumming group. It’s a Batalá Mundo event, so there will be drummers from all over the world! And we’ll all be decked out like skeletons and drumming in parades. Definitely a different way of celebrating for me!
My work in progress, the second book in my new cozy mystery series, is titled Bread of the Dead, and will prominently feature all the traditions, food, and celebrations of DÃa de Muertos. This will be my first time writing about the season while living it. Should be fun.
This month’s question asks: Many people are calling for writers who use AI to disclose it. Most who employ ghostwriters do not admit it – do you think authors who use ghostwriters should have to disclose that too?
I’m really glad this question isn’t actually about AI. I’m beyond sick of posts about AI, and of people losing their minds over it. Sigh.
Now, to the actual question. Many ghostwriters actually are credited. When you read a memoir or biography, and it says something like “Written by famous person and X,” X is the ghostwriter. But do I think they should always be credited?
I don’t think it would hurt. I’ve been a ghostwriter, though (still happy to be one if the right project materializes), and I’m glad my name isn’t attached to those projects. Not that there was anything ethically wrong with them–I just would never write anything like that if I was the one in control.
So I think it should be up to the ghostwriter. If they want the credit, then yes, they should be credited, at least as co-writer. But if they don’t, that should be respected too. One of the projects I worked on as a ghostwriter was conceptualized by a bunch of editors brainstorming the most ridiculous possible story, and hiring me and another writer to bring it to life. My co-writer had a bunch of other stuff going on, so she rarely communicated, and the end result is a hot mess. We had to go with the most contrived, cliche ending just to make the editors’ ideas work. So yeah, I’m glad my name is nowhere near that thing.
I’m sure you’ve already written about this for your own blog, so I’ll ask what you’re looking forward to most this month instead. What do you love about Spooky Season? Scary movies? Pumpkin spice lattes? Dressing up and handing out treats? Decorating the house? Inquiring minds want to know!
The purpose of the Insecure Writers’ Support Group is to share and encourage. Writers can express doubts anIWd concerns without fear of appearing foolish or weak.
Those who have been through the fire can offer assistance and guidance. It’s a safe haven for insecure writers of all kinds. To see a full list of IWSG authors, click here.
PS: If you’d like to see what I’m working on now, please hop on over to Patreon. It’s totally free to join, and I could really use a more vocal cheering section!

I didn’t know you were a drummer!
Never thought about a project being something a ghostwriter didn’t want his name attached to. Maybe that’s a good time to use a pen name.
Thanks for co-hosting!
In the case I talked about in the blog, there was one pen name used for all authors who wrote for that series, and I’m sure all of us are extremely grateful that crap isn’t attributed to us! LOL.
You brought up an point I hadn’t considered. I see ghostwriters as voluntarily entering into a contract that allows them to earn money writing without having to deal with the publishing and marketing side of the business, but I hadn’t considered putting their name on something they don’t have creative control of. It’s not the same as a co-author situation, and they might not WANT their name on the cover.
Thanks for co-hosting.
Yes, it’s tricky when probably a lot of people writing or commenting on this have never been a ghostwriter. If you have been, there’s a lot of nuance, and it really depends on the project. I’m glad you found something worthwhile in my ramblings!
You brought up something interesting. Good post. Thank you for co-hosting.
I don’t think a ghostwriter should control the material they write. The ideas belong to the author.
Have a great day, and thank you for co-hosting.
Shalom shalom
The author is the ghostwriter. And it depends on the project. In the case I was talking about in this blog, they wanted us to have creative control within the parameters of their original concept.
I guess there would be times you wouldn’t want your name on the book!
Most definitely! It should always be the ghostwriter’s choice.
I can see that — how there are definitely some projects that don’t fit with your normal niche of writing — wanting to remain anonymous.
Ugh, that book was such a disaster. Since Goodreads ranks us as authors based on our total body of work, including anthologies we only have one story in, I’m hugely grateful that cowritten mess isn’t attributed to me!
If you’re not a writer but have a compelling story to tell, then hiring a ghostwriter makes sense. I see no reason to call yourself a writer, then let a machine do all the work. Thanks for co-hosting today.
Good points! Not to mention AI writes terrible books (as an editor, I can attest to this). I would definitely want this declared on a book so I’d know what I was getting into if I bought it.
My word, what a fabulous take on this month’s question! You’ve opened my eyes to something I hadn’t thought about, and that is that ghostwriters have no actual control over the story they’re writing. They just have to make someone else’s ideas work. Fascinating. You’ve given me food for thought, so thank you.
As for your questions, I have to disappoint! We haven’t celebrated Halloween since the kids passed the age of twenty.
You’re very welcome, Yvette! Glad it resonated with you. As for Halloween, not even a cobweb, spider decal, or mini chocolate bar to be found?
You were the first to answer the question, so I thank you for that!
I’m no longer much of a Halloween fan which is strange since I used to be in the Halloween industry. Guess I got burn out. Or maybe I’m just getting old and crotchety. My house will be dark and inactive on Halloween night, much like many in my neighborhood. I’ll probably be watching a scary movie.
Lee
Nice to “see” you again, Arlee! I hear ya. I used to host this huge Halloween event for work, and after that, I had no interest in dressing up anymore. But I still like the season and the decor, movies, food, stories, etc.
As I understand it, most copywriters, especially for celebrities, are sworn to secrecy and paid quite well for it. I enjoyed this post and your thoughtful points – thanks! And, thank you for co-hosting. enjoy the drumming event!
Thanks, Diedre. It really depends on the ghostwriters and the arrangement. I’d say the majority are credited now. I read a lot of biographies and memoirs, and the ghostwriter is almost always credited.
I never knew you are an occasional ghostwriter. Now, that I do know, I think your opinion is the only one that counts, because you actually know what ghostwriting is about.
Aww, thank you, Olga. For years I belonged to Gotham Ghostwriters, though the project I mentioned was not one of theirs. I once auditioned for a project that turned out to be a James Patterson book (if I’d known who the author was, I definitely would have approached it differently), and almost ended up writing a book that made the case for Scott Peterson being innocent (kind of glad I didn’t get that gig).
I agree with you that ghostwriters should be credited when they help write a book and that they should be the ones to make that decision. Like you, I’m a ghostwriter. I work for a web marketing firm and write articles for my attorney clients’ websites, using the attorneys’ names on the articles posted there. I think that’s a totally different situation. Thanks for co-hosting this month.
Hi Natalie! Yes, totally different kind of ghostwriting. In that case, you’d know going in that you aren’t going to be credited, and you probably wouldn’t want to be. It is a bit disingenuous, though, as I assume most people who read those articles believe the attorneys wrote them. With your example, I can see why the question came about. Both using AI and ghostwriters deceive the reader to an extent.
Thanks to you and the others for co-hosting!
I can see why a ghostwriter wouldn’t want their name attached to a book for the reason you said. Something I didn’t really think about much until now.
I look forward to decorating the house for Halloween/Day of the Dead, watching horror movies, reading classic horror authors like Poe and Lovecraft, and discounted Halloween candy, especially chocolate!
Sounds perfect, Steven! I’m glad to see others are getting into the spirit. Do you make an ofrenda for Day of the Dead?
Thank you for hosting this month for IWSG and for letting us see behind the curtain and from the pov of an actual ghostwriter! Contracts may set out the guidelines, but it seems like they can also hide those who were deeply involved in helping create a work. I agree with you that ghostwriters deserve credit. Now, enjoy that drumming. I wish we were in Mexico to see that parade of dancing drummers! Enjoy!
Thanks so much, Beth. We deserve credit, but like I said, we might not always want it!
I may be able to share some videos or photos of the DÃa de Muertos event. I’m sure I will be.
Congrats on your new release, and thanks for visiting!
Great points based on your knowledge!
I’m truly looking forward to Halloween this year. I always put out books and sit outside to talk to everyone and watch as kids are more excited about getting to take books than candy. But last year I was toastmaster at a con up in Denver, and I was doing opening ceremonies Halloween night, so I missed out on all of it. I usually don’t dress up, but I have a pair of warm coveralls I used to clean out my greenhouse, so I can be Ripley for Halloween and be warm sitting outside in Colorado at the end of October.
Also, one year I’d love to experience Dia de Muertos, but I think not in Playa del Carmen where it would probably be flooded with tourists. (I openly admit I’m a tourist in that case, too, but I’m big on traveling to places off season to deal with as few fellow tourists as possible. Even in the U.S. There’s a mountain town I love to visit in winter when no one’s there but locals, because the culture is entirely different during that time.) My city is a big tourist town, and I don’t go to certain places during the summer.
Shannon, I LOVE that you give books away on Halloween as well as candy! You are seriously the coolest person. Where do you get them from?
And ugh, I’d never want to go to Playa del Carmen or any place like it again. Tepoztlán will probably be a bit busy for DDM, as it’s known for it, but I’m guessing the majority will be Mexican tourists. I’d suggest coming to my neck of the woods, but our celebrations are a lot smaller. Not a lot to see here in way of festivities, as it’s a little fishing village. But if you want authentic Mexico, it’s much closer to a real experience than some place like Playa del Carmen.
DÃa de Muertos sounds like so much fun! Halloween has always been my favourite holiday, especially because of its pagan roots. Although seeing all the kids dressed up when they’re trick-or-treating is adorable!
I love the pagan traditions of Halloween! When I worked for a museum, I used to make the rounds on local media every year, explaining why we dress up, trick or treat, etc. It was really interesting and a lot of fun. My favourite is why witches are shown wearing pointed hats.
People don’t realize that ghostwriting is difficult for most writers. First, you are usually dealing with a property that isn’t yours (TV show, movie, game, etc.) so you have to follow strict plot and character guidelines. Then you have to expand the screenplay without changing what happened in the movie. And if the IP wasn’t great to begin with… uh oh! The nice thing is they usually pay well. And it’s a true payment, not an advance.
I admire those who do it – I never could.
Now, as for spooky season… not much to say these days. Here in southern NC it’s getting cooler finally (70s instead of 90s!) but still wearing our shorts. Pumpkin spice season is upon us, so that’s good. The house is decorated, but not as much as in previous years. We have a new rule, because in this house, unlike NY, we actually use the garage for more than storage, so whenever a decoration bites the dust, it can’t get replaced by something larger. And we no longer have giant ones hanging off the house.
Plans for the month include a trip to NY to check on mom, a Halloween-themed book signing event, a comedy show, and possibly a visit to a walk-through haunted attraction in the woods (weather permitting).
Your month sounds much better!
Are you kidding, JG? A haunted attraction in the woods and the Halloween-themed book signing sound AWESOME! I’m so envious. Halloween is really lame here, but that’s actually a good thing, because I want Mexico to keep its own traditions and not be so influenced by ours. The inevitable is happening, as more and more foreigners move here, but DÃa de Muertos is such a beautiful tradition, and so different from Halloween. I hope it always stays the focus.
Are you saying you don’t have your tree anymore? I loved that tree! Please say you still have the tree.
I wish my payment for that one book had been better. LOL. We were promised it was going to be one of many, but because of the weird decisions made by the publisher (like turning it into serial fiction, where readers had to pay four or five times for the same book), it bombed, and as far as I know, no more were written. My editor also left the publisher before it was released. Le sigh. This industry, right?
Like many others, I hadn’t thought about the ghostwriter not wanting to have their name on a project. Certainly they should have that right, as well as the right to get credit for their work. But either way, I don’t think anyone should claim a work as theirs if they had it ghostwritten. As you note, there’s usually a “written with” sort of note, but it’s often kind of buried.
True, but often now it’s right on the cover, at least with the big celebrity memoirs and bios I read. My friend JG Faherty brought up a good point too…a lot of ghostwriters work on franchise novels. Things like fiction derived from movies and TV shows. You often do get your name on those–Chuck Wendig’s first bestseller was a Star Wars book–but you’re under so many constraints, I’m not sure you would want your name on it.
There are books even the AI wouldn’t want to put their name on.
For the last six years we’ve done very involved haunted house/escape rooms for my kids and nieces (really involved – like having to repaint the house afterward involved). My father-in-law passed away last year right before Halloween and my wife and I still threw something together last minute.
This year it looks like we won’t be able to pull anything together. It just doesn’t feel the same. Plus the kids are getting to an age that they don’t appreciate it the same way anymore, so it takes away some of the magic. :-/
Aww, damn! I’m really sorry to hear that, CD. It sounds so amazing. I wish I could have seen some of the ones you did in years past. I’m sorry to hear about the loss of your father-in-law too. I’m sure that anniversary casts a shadow over the season.
Your comment about AI made me laugh! So true. It can totally take the credit for that monstrosity I cowrote if it wants!
Kids not willing to participate in Halloween because they feel too old???OMG! Tell them they either join in and enjoy it, or they can go live somewhere else (tough love, baby). It’s good practise for when their own kids feel that they’re too old to take part. Being a Brit, Halloween has only really caught on here during the last 15 years or so, but being a Horror buff, I love seeing all the kids and sometimes even their parents, dressed up to scare. I make little Halloween bags of goodies and the smiles on their faces are with every bit of the effort. My greatest fear is that one year I’ll run out :(:(:( Hasn’t happened yet, mind you. I usually end up giving my spares to the primary school up the street (More smiles).
Oh, that sounds so fun, Mark. Good for you for doing that! I’m sure you’ll make lots of kids happy. You don’t keep any of the treats?
Ha ha, believe it or not I haven’t eaten chocolate or sweets for nearly ten years now. I started this healthy eating kick to try and lose weight and get into better shape. Since then I’ve managed to gain about 50lbs, my waistline has shot up to sub-human proportions, my overall health has never been worse…I’m beginning to think I must be doing something wrong here 🙂
I’m not sure if you’re joking or not! You’re in worse shape since going on a healthy-eating kick?
No joke, I promise, my one (and only) pleasure food and drink-wise now is the occasional glass of wine with dinner. Alas, due to 2 slipped discs and crippling arthritis in my knees i can barely move these days, so I imagine everything I eat just sits there gathering more fat. I’m on (extensive) hospital lists for both conditions and have been for years now (good old NHS, once the envy of the modern world, now just a not-so-funny joke for those of us on the receiving end). Hey-ho, enough about my trials of woe. I hope you have a fabulous time at your festival. I’ll still be sitting outside (freezing) handing out my little treat bags to the monsters who pass by my door 🙂
I’m so sorry to hear about this, Mark. That sounds absolutely horrible. I don’t know how I’d manage.
You are correct. Ghostwriters should have the option to remain anonymous if they wish. It IS a contractual agreement. All the luck with your travelling. Sounds exciting. Thank you for cohosting this month’s question.
Thanks! I’m a bit nervous about it (lots to learn), but I’m sure it’ll be amazing.
You are the perfect person to answer this month’s IWSG question. This is an interesting topic!!
First, I thought, of course ghostwriters should be credited. Then, I read your answer and I have to agree with you. It should be up to the ghostwriter. Then, again, the term “ghostwriter” assumes that the actual writer doesn’t take credit for it. Hmmm…
Enjoy Dia de Muertos! I’m sure it’ll be a blast, being part of it as a drummer. So. Darn. Cool!
No spooky season for me. I’ve never related to Halloween (as a Belgian) or have dress-up clothes (as a minimalist). Plus, we have no time for fun at the moment, working full-time on our next home on wheels. 🙂
Aww, damn! There should always be room for fun.
I don’t dress up anymore, either, but this time I’ll be wearing the Batalá costume (worn for parades and some performances) and have my face Catarina’d up for DÃa de Muertos. Looking forward to that part! Should be fun.
Thanks for the kind words, and good luck with the “house” work.
That sounds like a crazy project! And hello! It’s been a while since we ran across each other out here of wilds of the internet. Glad to see you’re doing well!
Hello, Sam! I still see your IG posts from time to time.
And yeah, it really was. I was provided with a pic of Chris Hemsworth and told to envision him as “my” (the protagonist’s) husband.
¡Gracias for co-hosting! I love how hyped you are for the holiday. The colors and designs of Dia de los Muertos are mesmerizing. And how cool you’re incorporating it into your WIP.
Thanks so much, Jennifer! Big fan of DÃa de Muertos, for sure. 🙂
One thing I haven’t seen people distinguish between ghostwriting and AI is the reality that ghostwriting at some level is a collaboration between the writer and the person who’s taking public credit for the work. With AI there is no collaboration. I like the idea of the ghostwriter deciding if they want the credit or not. The one time I ghost wrote something it was part of the agreement that I was compensated but didn’t want credit. I assumed all ghostwriting aggreements covered that in some capacity.
In my experience, the contracts do cover that. I think that with AI-assisted writing, there should be a collaboration. Even though AI can’t collaborate as a human would, it can follow prompts and make adjustments. The one AI-generated book I’ve received from a client was terrible, but if she’d collaborated more instead of letting AI do all the work, she could have had something decent. Sadly, she didn’t, and thought I wouldn’t notice.